As if I didn't have enough to do, I ordered about five books for my Kindle. The first I read was this one. I don't really think it was worth my money. Not to say it was a bad book, though.
The thing is, if you know anything about the common core, then this book will rehash everything. If you, like me, were thinking of buying this book because you wanted to use the advertised grading scales that were made for each standard and included in the book, don't bother. If you own Marzano's Classroom Assessment and Grading That Work, all the Common Core version does is put the standards into the four-point rubric. That's pretty much it. I'm pretty sure I am able to do that myself without spending about $20 to have someone else do that for me.
Now, the one saving grace of the book is the chapter that teaches the processes for various cognitive strategies. These would be helpful for me in the classroom. I liked reading how Marzano and his team suggest breaking down how to teach a cognitive process such as generating a conclusion or presenting and supporting claims. They would make excellent lessons and mini-lessons in the classroom. These are the strategies that are truly helpful for my students.
Overall, I would give this book a D. The only helpful part of the book for me was the section on cognitive processes. The rest was a rewrite of many of his previous books and research. As a busy teacher (and I quote), "Ain't nobody got time for that."
I've been toying with the idea of buying Marzano's Classroom Assessment and Grading That Work, but haven't yet; which of these two books would you recommend?
ReplyDeleteIf it matters, I'm a first year high school English teacher, with two years of 6th grade experience.
I definitely think both books have their merits, so it really depends on what you find yourself struggling with, on which you would like more information, or which your new school is focusing on for the year. I say this because, if you find yourself questioning how to set up grading in your classroom or want help writing general rubrics, then Classroom Assessment and Grading that Work will be helpful. If you are worried about going to Common Core and want more help figuring out how to set up units and assessments for the Common Core specifically, then I would recommend Using Common Core Standards.
DeleteIf you have more questions or need help with the transition to high school, please let me know. I'd be happy to share any of my resources with you! And thanks for commenting!
Thanks! I think my main struggle is creating meaningful assessments. For example, how do I meaningfully assess reading comprehension without assessing writing? Should those be two distinct skills in high school, or not since it seems like Common Core is blending those skills together more and more? Also, how do I meaningfully assess students without drowning in grading? (These are just general questions-not necessarily things I expect to get definitive answers to!)
ReplyDeleteI dig your blog-makes me want to get back on the blogging train! Happy writing! :-)
I could not stop smiling after your comment--Thanks! As far as assessment goes, I think the book you probably want (one that, in my mind, is more practical and less theoretical) is Chris Tovani's So What Do They Really Know? She discusses how to assess using various formative methods and how not to get dragged into the grading black hole. Between Marzano and Tovani you should have a good background in assessment!
Delete